Death Used to Ride This Curve…

Holiday accidents took their toll as motorists started on their Labor Day week end. Early yesterday Joseph Morris and his brother’s wife, Charlotte, were killed when this car overturned in Bronx Park. The driver, Anthony Morris, Navy purchasing agent, was injured. Three other auto deaths had been listed last night, the Motor Vehicle Bureau says about 40 will die before Tuesday in New York State. PM Daily, August 31, 1941, p. 18

PM Daily, August 31, 1941, p. 18

In the 1940s PM Daily campaigned tirelessly (small pun) for automobile (and consumer and labor, etc.) safety. And Weegee, a person who spent a fair amount of his time in his maroon 1938 Chevy (sometimes listening to the “egghead” radio station WQXR and/or a police radio), often provided photos of some of the Naked City’s most dangerous streets. The photos were at times enhanced by PM’s great art department… Seventy summers ago, PM focused its’ attention on Robert Moses’ relatively new Henry Hudson Parkway (1934-1937) and its 72d St. entrance…

PM Daily, July 21, 1940, p. 10 (photos by Weegee and Wide World)

Chief Danger Point on Henry Hudson Parkway Is at 72d St. Entrance
Since March 30 last year ten cars have crashed into light poles or the guard rail (shown in photograph left) with a toll of four dead, 19 injured. Police say that no correctable driving hazard exists at this point, contend that a reasonable amount of caution on the part of motorists would have averted the accidents.
The Park Department, however, which was responsible for designing and construction of the parkway, is now making a study of this situation.
Curious facts about these crashes:
None has involved a collision of cars.
In all cases but one (a blowout), car was southbound.
In all cases but two (driver treated for alcoholism in one), accidents occurred between midnight and 6 a.m., when traffic on the parkway is lightest.

In the Spring of 1941, perhaps as a result of PMs’ words and images, this deadly stretch of parkway was improved and made safer. PM, never shy to give itself credit for righting a wrong and making the world a better place to live, re-published the page (with a new photo by Martin Harris) on March 14, 1941:

PM Daily, March 14, 1941, p. 12 (photos by Weegee, Martin Harris, and Wide World)

Death Used to Ride This Curve.
Seven months ago, on July 21, PM portrayed in story and pictures, reproduced at left, the auto death trap at the 72nd Street entrance to the Henry Hudson Parkway. Experts couldn’t explain why accidents occured at that particular spot but the statistics for 1940 added up to this: seven accidents, two killed, ten injured.
A study of the accidents showered that almost all involved southbound cars making the slight curve to the West Side elevated highway, none were collisions, and most occurred between midnight and 6 a.m., when light traffic invites speeding.
The cars involved crashed into the high curb that divided the lanes or into electric light stanchions; often-until it was removed-into a police booth.
With these curious facts to work on, engineers of the Park Department recently undertook to remove the hazard. After extensive study, they installed heavy guard rails and softened the curb.
The death curve as it looks today is shown above. The work was completed on Feb. 18, two weeks ago. There have been no accidnts since, but only time will tell whether the curious problem has been solved.

In the fall of 1941 PM highlighted a deadly part of the West Side Highway…

PM Daily, October 14, 1941, p. 15 (photos by Weegee)

32 People Have Died on This West Side Highway Curve
There’s a murderous curve on the West Side Highway at Little W. 12th St., that has claimed the lives of 32 motorists since the drive was finished in 1930.
Three have died in crashes on this sharp-angled turn in the last three days, two on Saturday night, another last night. Two others are critical condition in hospitals.
Police who patrol the section say it is the wickedest spot for an automobile driver in or around New York. A rule-straight stretch approaches it and it looms up without warning. Maybe the latest death toll will spur city authorities to some action toward eliminating the danger, either by banking or rounding off the vicious twist.
Joseph J. Donovan, 51, of Brooklyn, was last night’s victim. He was a passenger in a car driven by Cornelius Murphy, 38. Missing the turn, the machine smashed into the concrete island, hit a pole and ended up against the retaining wall. Donovan was killed instantly. Murphy is in St. Vincent’s hospital under a charge of motor-vehicle homicide. He has a possible skull fracture.
Of the three men in a car, which took an almost identical course to disaster Saturday night, two were killed and a third is in a hospital. Little hope is held for a recovery.

Three middle-aged men were on their way home after visiting friends early Saturday morning. The machine in which they were riding failed to make the turn. It climbed the concrete island curbing, tore across the roadway and smashed with terrific force into the retaining wall. the metal body was literally ripped from the frame and the whole machine was reduced to this crumpled mass. Carlo Marino, is in St. Vincent’s Hospital with a fractured skull and multiple lacerations. He may die. When police and ambulances arrived Dominico Palnizzo, 50, and Dominick Caspaglione, 50, were dead, killed instantly in the crash. The sharpness of the turn is indicated by the white broken lines.

And in the winter of 1942 PM turned it’s attention to East 155th Street, (before another of Robert Moses’ creations, the Franklin D. Roosevelt East River Drive reached 155th St.).

PM Daily, February 24, 1942, p. 3 (photos by Weegee and Irving Haberman)

1. At 5:10 yesterday morning, an automobile, traveling 50 m.p.h., plunged straight along the dotted line into the Harlem River. It should have turned right, following the arrow. There are no signs at this 155th St. corner to tell drivers to turn. Until yesterday afternoon, firemen failed to find the car by dragging the river. Police boats had similar bad luck most of the day. They called for expert help…

2. Late in the afternoon, Thomas Walsh, 78-year-old diver, went into icy river, located car, and affixed hooks…

3. At 9 last night, the car, a shiny, black Buick, with Rhode Island license plates, was hoisted out of the river by a tug. Body of a Negro (feet are visible) was found in the car. Police Sgt. William Wilson eyewitnessed accident.

Three years later Weegee framed (a variant of) this image differently in Naked City…

Weegee, Naked City, 1945, p.88

It’s a lovely evening… the full moon is out. A car somehow or other drives off the pier into the river. The couples in the parked cars in “Lovers’ Lane,” as the pier is called, run out of the cars dressed in pajamas. Police boats arrive with powerful searchlights which illuminate the waters as other cops try to get a “bite” on the car. It is a long trying job to locate the car in the river.

Fortunately there were fewer people killed by cars in 2009 than in any of the previous 100 years:
Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg and the brilliant Department of Transportation Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan announced in January that New York City traffic fatalities fell to an all-time record low in 2009. Last year, there were 256 traffic fatalities in New York City, 12 percent fewer than in 2008, and a 35 percent reduction compared to 2001. The previous record low was in 2007, with 274 fatalities. Traffic safety records have been kept in New York City since 1910.

And the fantastic car-free Broadway in Times Square has become permanent! Or as permanent as anything in the Naked City…

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s